āSweet Promises or Hidden Pitfalls? Questioning Mamdaniās Welfare Visionā
āSweet Promises or Hidden Pitfalls? Questioning Mamdaniās Welfare Visionā
I live in NYC, struggling with rent, subway fares, and childcare while politicians treat us like invisible people. When Zohran Mamdani emergedāan immigrant, democratic socialist promising free buses, rent freeze, city-owned supermarketsāI thought: finally, someone sees us.
His grassroots campaign blew past Cuomo in that ranked-choice primaryāfelt like a movie moment. But then, Trump attacked him as āpure communist lunaticā whoād destroy New Yorkās economy. That got me thinking: Are these buzzwords political smoke screensāor is there a real risk?
Mamdani denies being a communist. But some of his words echo radical ideasālike āseize the means of productionāāand experts warn city-run groceries and public housing might be inefficient in real life. Plus, his hard stance against billionairesāāthey should disappearāācould scare off donors. If wealthy philanthropists pull out, will funding for museums, hospitals, universities dry up?
Iām torn. On one hand, his message speaks to us. On the other, I wonder: Is welfare really welfare when it throws the whole city off balance? Free stuff is amazingāuntil no one funds the city.